Welcome to Bonanno's New York Pizza Kitchen, a culinary gem nestled within the vibrant Soaring Eagle Casino in Mt Pleasant, Michigan. Here, the art of New York-style pizza is celebrated, from the large, delectable slices to the inviting aroma that fills the air. This restaurant has quickly made a name for itself among pizza enthusiasts looking for a taste of authenticity.
At Bonanno's, the menu caters to a diverse palate, showcasing more than just pizza. The freshly baked Calzone stands out with its savory fillings of cheese, spinach, ham, or chicken, served alongside marinara sauce for the perfect dip—just for $11.99. The 6 Piece Wing Combo is a crowd favorite, featuring crispy wings dressed in the sauce of your choice, accompanied by either fries or garlic knots, all for $13.99. For those who crave variety, the 2 Slice Combo and 10 Piece Wing Combo deliver an explosive combination of flavors that pizza lovers won't want to miss.
Customer reviews echo the restaurant's commitment to quality. Ryan Novak praises Bonanno's as "the best new place in town," highlighting the freshness of their pizza and the flavor-packed Stromboli. Michael T reflects on his experience, expressing satisfaction with the pizza's quality and the stellar garlic knots that earned an A+ rating. Each review paints a picture of Bonanno's as a friendly neighborhood pizzeria, where service is just as important as the food, with staff members like Ryan and Matthew leaving a lasting impression on guests.
As you settle into this welcoming space, it's hard not to feel the warmth of camaraderie and the joy that comes with sharing great food. The exciting addition of specialty pizzas keeps the menu fresh, while classic favorites like the pepperoni Stromboli continue to delight loyal customers. Whether you're here for a hearty meal or a casual snack, Bonanno's New York Pizza Kitchen is committed to delivering a dining experience that invites you to come back for more.
In essence, each bite at Bonanno’s is a celebration of flavor, tradition, and community—a place where pizza is crafted with care and passion. Come visit us at Soaring Eagle Blvd, or give us a call at +1 888-732-4537; we can't wait for you to taste the magic!
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
2010 Black River St, Deckerville, MI 48427, United States
26505 Ford Rd, Dearborn Heights, MI 48127, United States
1802 28th St SW, Wyoming, MI 49519, United States
25000 Greenfield Rd, Oak Park, MI 48237, United States
163 W Maple Rd, Birmingham, MI 48009, United States
122 N Adams Rd, Rochester, MI 48309, United States
2755 Arena Dr, Hartland, MI 48353, United States
17700 8 Mile Rd, Harper Woods, MI 48225, United States
302 S Bullock St, Whittemore, MI 48770, United States
8400 S Genuine Rd, Shepherd, MI 48883, United States
TIS Square, MT Haryono St No.52 Unit 12, West Tebet, Tebet, South Jakarta City, Jakarta 12810, Indonesia
Jl. Raya Utan Jaya Gg. Widuri No.107, RT.4/RW5, Pd. Jaya, Kec. Cipayung, Kota Depok, Jawa Barat 16438, Indonesia
7XVG+5GH, Sa Nok Kaeo, Phon Thong District, Roi Et 45110, Thailand
C. Los Vascos, 2, 28250 Torrelodones, Madrid, Spain
127 Liverpool St, Sydney NSW 2000, Australia
Discover new menus and trending dishes on Menustic.
Menustic helps you discover menus from restaurants, cafés, and bars around the world. Explore destinations, compare dishes and prices, and decide where to eat or drink — Fantastic Menus, One Click Away.
© 2026 Menustic. Built to help people discover menus and decide what to eat and drink.
Ryan Novak
08/10/2025
Some people have been saying not great things, however, I feel like this is the best new place in town! Yes, sometimes there is a bit of a wait but this isn’t like Little Caesar’s! They reheat the pizza and it is amazing! Large slices! And the Stromboli is delicious! Would recommend a try! 11/10 for me!
Michael T
24/09/2025
Really good New York style pizza last night at Soaring Eagle. Hadn't tried it but finally gave it a shot. Great pepperoni slice and a solid plain slice. Garlic knots were A+ and a must try. Ryan was a nice pizza maker with good service.
Leanne Lockhart
19/09/2025
We had pizza at the restaurant on Friday night inside soaring eagle casino in Mount pleasant Michigan. The pizza was amazing and the young man that help us . Ryan was very helpful on helping us choose what we wanted.
Kassi Hughes
18/09/2025
Bonanno's has amazing pizza, and Matthew makes great stromboli's. If he is working, I would definitely ask him to make the Stromboli. Keep up the great work :)
Jairo Burgalin
23/08/2025
Great pizza spot inside the soaring eagle casino. I’ve been eating here for a while and they just keep getting better. They have new specialties pizzas which made their selection even better. The pepperoni stramboli never fails. Stephanie today took care of me and was super helpful with great customer service.
Crystal Brewer
28/07/2025
Stopped in after playing bingo, was starving. Ryan was so pleasant to work with. We saw him cleaning tables helping out co workers. The bread sticks were amazing and fresh can't wait to return and try something different.
FA Hayek
28/07/2025
NY style pizza, it’s crispy, it’s fresh, very solid
Chrome Rims
27/06/2025
Was at the casino last night decided I needed some food.. Went to the food court and got a Stromboli would highly suggest that! Also Stephanie was quick and great service and really nice. 5 stars highly recommend!